I stumbled on the BBA Challenge several months ago at Pinch My Salt. I’m a little late to the party but hoping to catch up in the next month or so.
Day 1 – The Soaker
I set aside yesterday afternoon to make this bread, but it turned out that I only needed about 5 minutes for Step 1. Step 1 is the “soaker”: mix one cup of cornmeal with 1 cup water and leave standing overnight at room temperature.
I was still in a baking mood after that, so I tried out a scones recipe from another baking book. It was my first attempt ever at making scones, and although they were very tasty with lemon zest as one of the ingredients and a dusting of cinnamon sugar on top, they came out of the oven a mass of ugly white baked blobs. My 9-year-old daughter offered to help me get rid of them. She calls things like this my “not-turnouts” and informed me yesterday that she’s willing to eat any not-turnouts that I make unless, you know, it’s salad or something like that.
Day 2 – The Sponge (and remaining steps)
After letting the soaker sit overnight, it was time to create the “sponge” by adding flour, salt, instant yeast and warm water and allowing the mixture to ferment for an hour or so.

Peter Reinhart recommends using instant yeast in most of his formulas, and can I just say here that after struggling for a long time with regular yeast, which is temperamental and high maintenance, instant yeast (also called “bread machine” and “quick rise” yeast) is the best. invention. ever.


When the sponge was done fermenting, it was time to mix in the remaining ingredients to make the dough. I used my Kitchenaid for mixing, swapped in the dough hook to start the kneading process, and then finished kneading by hand.



When the dough was supple, resilient and tacky without being sticky, I shaped it into a ball and placed it in a lightly oiled bowl to ferment for another hour or so. Then I went for a run.

When I came home, the dough had doubled in size.

I divided it in two halves, shaped them into loaves and placed them in 9×5 loaf pans. This is the proofing stage, where the dough rests again for another 60-90 minutes. I still had a couple of hours before my daughter’s school bus, so I headed back outside to rollerblade. (It was sunny and mild, which is highly unusual for November in Chicago, and Chicagoans know better than to take days like this for granted.)

At this point you may be thinking “what a lot of work over a loaf of bread,” and it’s true that Peter Reinhart’s formulas contain a lot of steps and many of them take more than one day to make. But it’s a methodical prep-and-rest, prep-and-rest process, and once your hard work is done and the bread is in the oven, there’s no better reward than wonderful baking aromas permeating your home.

I believe that my loaf pans may have been a little large for the amount of dough I used. It was supposed to crest over the top of the pan during proofing but didn’t quite make it.

This bread has a slightly chewy crust and soft center with a hint of sweetness. It makes a great sandwich bread (tried it with tuna salad earlier this evening) and I’m going to warm up a slice in the morning and spread it with melty butter.
